Key Points:
- Kiran Rao’s “Laapataa Ladies” is facing plagiarism accusations due to similarities with the 2019 Arabic short film “Burqa City.”
- The viral scene comparisons highlight specific narrative overlaps, such as the mistaken identity of veiled brides.
- Social media users are questioning Bollywood’s originality and drawing debates about the line between inspiration and imitation.
- Similar allegations were raised earlier about its resemblance to another film, “Ghunghat Ke Pat Khol” (1999).
- The filmmakers have not yet addressed these plagiarism accusations.
Plagiarism Allegations Against “Laapataa Ladies”
Kiran Rao’s light-hearted dramedy, “Laapataa Ladies,” has come under fire after facing plagiarism accusations. The spark for this controversy is a viral video clip from the 2019 Arabic short film “Burqa City,” directed by Fabrice Bracq. Social media users noted striking similarities between the concept and scenes from the two movies.
Similar Scenes and Comparisons
In “Burqa City,” the story revolves around a newlywed man searching for his wife after she is mistakenly swapped with another burqa-clad woman. A humorous scene from the film shows the police laughing at the protagonist when presented with a photo of a veiled woman, pointing out the impossibility of recognizing her due to the burqa.
These elements mirror the narrative in “Laapataa Ladies,” where Deepak, the protagonist, embarks on a similar search for his bride after she is swapped with another woman wearing a “ghoonghat” on a train. Ravi Kishan’s character, much like the police officer in “Burqa City,” ridicules Deepak when presented with a similar veiled photo.
Public Reaction
The similarities between “Laapataa Ladies” and “Burqa City” have led to widespread disappointment online. Here are a few notable reactions:
- A user questioned, “So what will you call it? Inspiration or Copy?”
- “There is nothing original about Bollywood anymore,” commented another, hinting at a lack of creativity in the industry.
- One thoughtful critique stated, “If Rao’s film mirrors key aspects of ‘Burqa City,’ it raises questions about originality and the line between inspiration and imitation.” The user also acknowledged that although the core themes of patriarchy and identity are universal, crediting the source of inspiration is vital, particularly with international platforms like the Oscars.
Previous Plagiarism Claims
This is not the first time “Laapataa Ladies” has been accused of being unoriginal. In July 2024, actor Ananth Mahadevan alleged that the film bore a remarkable resemblance to his debut directorial work, “Ghunghat Ke Pat Khol” (1999).
About “Laapataa Ladies”
Directed by Kiran Rao and produced by Aamir Khan, “Laapataa Ladies” features a fresh cast, including Pratibha Ranta, Nitanshi Goel, and Sparsh Shrivastava. The film has received critical acclaim and accolades, including sweeping awards at the IIFA 2025.
However, these plagiarism allegations cast a shadow over its achievements and reputation, placing its originality under scrutiny.
FAQs
1. What is the plagiarism controversy about “Laapataa Ladies”?
The film has been accused of borrowing its concept and scenes from the 2019 Arabic short film “Burqa City.” Key narrative similarities, including a swapped bride storyline and comedic police reactions to veiled photos, have led to these allegations.
2. Has “Laapataa Ladies” faced plagiarism claims before?
Yes, in 2024, the film was accused of resembling the 1999 film “Ghunghat Ke Pat Khol,” directed by Ananth Mahadevan.
3. How have audiences reacted to the controversy?
The reactions online have been mixed. While some criticized Bollywood for lacking originality, others acknowledged the universal themes but stressed the importance of recognizing sources.
4. Have the filmmakers responded to the accusations?
No, the filmmakers have yet to issue an official statement addressing the plagiarism claims.
5. Who are the main cast members of “Laapataa Ladies”?
The movie features Pratibha Ranta, Nitanshi Goel, and Sparsh Shrivastava in lead roles.
